Definitely order up in size. I normally wear a size 8.5 and wasn't sure if I should order an 8 or 9 in this shoe as it only comes in whole sizes. I am happy I chose to go with a 9 as this size just fits, with my heel at the edge of the shoe.
Defective sandal - These seemed to fit me really well at first, but after talking a short walk in them, I realized that the leather on the left sandal was warped and stretched much larger than the right shoe. It was so loose that I couldn't even keep the sandal on my foot, so back they went. I was sad because I really wanted a pair of leather Reefs.
Deceptively lightweight and funky - Just received these and want to like them. Great quality!!! Put on my favorite mid-weight (40% wool) socks and they feel tight across instep and a little bit at the heel. Not much arch support. Ordered the 8.5 as other reviewers said it felt a half size larger, but I don't think so and probably wish I had sized up.
Decent Moc - Good looking shoe, but it felt a half size smaller than marked. A little stiff on the feet at first but improving the longer I wear it. Good sole for outdoor wear. Overall, satisfied with the purchase of this Moc.
DC Pure SE W - The top of the shoe under the laces near the toes is a little uncomfortable if you tie the laces loose. Other than that, I like them.
David Tate Starglow - Love this shoe, but need to put something "non-slip" inside the strap in back of the ankle. Not a problem with the shoe, it's a problem with my foot. Definitely wide enough and very comfortable.
